Sydney AFL Medalists
| Phelan Medal | |||
| Harry Maguire | 2023 | ||
| Stephen Wray | 2022 | ||
| Ranga Ediriwickrama | 2019 | ||
| Alex Goodall | 2014 | ||
| Kieran Wright | 2011 | ||
| Matthew Carey | 2008 | ||
| Charlie Richardson | 2007 | ||
| Gary Spillane | 1988 | ||
| Mick Toy | 1983 | ||
| Snow Medal | |||
| Patrick Witt | 2023 | ||
| Patrick Witt | 2018 | ||
| Tim Scoular | 2020 | ||
| Sanders Medal | |||
| Hayden Benger | 2006 | ||
| Doug Scholz | 1997 & 1998 | ||
| Steve Monahan | 1993 | ||
| Paul Woods | 1984 | ||
| Jim Dempster | 1982 | ||
| McFarlane Medal | |||
| Nathan Breen | 2016 | ||
| Peter Mathers | 1975 & 1976 | ||
| Granland Medal | |||
| Alex Huggins | 2018 | ||
| Apted Medal | |||
| Kieran Wright | 2020 | ||
| Armstrong Medal | |||
| Alex Huggins | 2013 | ||
| John Rakic | 2001 | ||
| Frank Piccolo | 2000 & 2003 | ||
| Kealy Medal | |||
| Dylan Bonham | 2023 | ||
| Lukas De Vries | 2015 | ||
| Dean Connors | 2002 | ||
| Simon Collins | 1997 | ||
| Grant Broderick | 1995 | ||
| Stuart Williams | 1988 | ||
| Brendan Hellard | 1980 | ||
| Rod Podbury Medal | |||
| – Best on Ground in Premier Division Grand Final | |||
| Damian Dell’Aquila | 2015 | (Win) | |
| Scott Reed | 2008 | (Win) | |
| Barnaby Howarth | 2000 | (Win) | |
| Chris Yard | 1996 | (Loss) | |
| Sydney AFL Rising Star | |||
| Cameron Mitchell | 2023 | ||
| Harry Maguire | 2019 | ||
| Aaron Crisfield | 2007 | ||
| Nick Potter | 2003 | ||
